The Warren Buffet Lie

From the President down to the water cooler, we hear that Warren Buffet pays a lower tax rate than his secretary. That is simply untrue.

The fallacious statement is based on the assumption that his secretary pays about 25% of her income in FICA and income taxes while Buffet pays a 15% rate on capital gains and qualified dividends. It sounds terribly unfair, but it ignores the double taxation of investment income.

The claim that investors are taxed at lower rates than wage earners is built on the fiction that a corporation exists independently from its investors. It does not, a corporation is just a group of people acting together to conduct a business. This artificial division between the corporation as an entity and its shareholders allows government to take two bites at the same profit apple.

What Buffet really pays, as a part owner of those businesses, is his share of the corporate tax rate of up to 35% plus 15% of what’s left. Shareholders in a business are partial owners and receive a share of the profits.

If Buffet’s share of the profits of a business in which he is a shareholder is $100, 35% of that $100 goes to corporate taxes before he gets his dividend of $65. He then pays 15% tax on that $65, or $9.75, leaving him with $55.25 of his original $100 share in the profits. In some cases, ‘Green energy’ tax credits and such reduce the corporate tax rate but the principle still applies. Dividends are what’s left after corporate taxes are taken.

So, Buffet’s real Federal  tax rate is up to 44.75%, not 15%. Add in State corporate and personal investment income taxes, and government skims off well over half the profit Buffet receives on his investment before he can spend a dime.

If secretaries were paying that kind of tax rate, we would have riots in the streets.

2 Responses to The Warren Buffet Lie

  1. Outstanding. Hopefully, you mailed to the editor. This needs to be widely read and to counter idiots such as Eugene Robinson’s propaganda in today’s editorial pages.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: