Keeping an eye on our freedom of mobility.

Road-Use System to Get Test in Maryland
Baltimore Sun (10/20/08) Dresser, Michael

A federally-funded study being conducted in six states will test a system that could supplant the federal gasoline tax with road-use fees. During the study, a global satellite positioning system will track how many miles motorists drive in eight months, and will also note whether the state, federal, or local government pays for the roads they take. The study will also observe how participants react to the idea. Critics of the gas tax claim it will continue to decrease as a revenue source for road improvement as technology enhances mileage. Those who back the road-use fee maintain that it would distribute funds more accurately than the gas tax. Under a system where fees are based on road usage, users would get a bill every month showing how many miles they drove, in addition to when and where. Jon Kuhl, principal investigator with the Iowa Public Policy Center, says that exact locations to which the automobile has traveled will not be included in the data that the system gathers.


So, what happens when people fail to pay the bill? Jail time? Garnish wages? Tow away and impound their vehicles? Endless late fees pilled up?

Is the data regarding exact location of where each vehicle traveled stored or made otherwise available – and for whom, how? What safeguards do we citizens have to prevent and to punish abuses of our privacy? Violating our privacy should be a criminal offense and not just a civil matter.

Will public transit riders also be billed for their road usage each month?

What about federal, state, regional, and local governments?

What about non-profit organizations?

What about businesses?

Who gets a free ride – and who decides who will pay and who doesn’t?

Will private businesses be awarded contracts as toll collectors? How much profit will they be allowed to exort from the citizens?

What are YOUR thoughts?


3 Responses to Keeping an eye on our freedom of mobility.

  1. Chad says:

    Despite its flaws, I liked the general flow of the system in Houston. The main interstates were toll roads based (generally speaking) on distance traveled; every time you go through a toll station you pay a toll. For people with ez-passes, the system was transparent… you go through the toll at full speed (!) and you keep on driving. Alternate lanes for cash only payment were available… and you could avoid the fees altogether by making use of the service roads, albeit at a slower speed.

    I have no problem with people paying for the services they use, as long as it is done in a cost effective and efficient manner.

  2. Reid Greenmun says:

    Chad, this approach will make all roada a “toll road”.

  3. Chad P says:

    I understand that and I’m against any government agency tracking my movements, if only because government has a tendency to break the boundaries set by the people wherever it thinks it can get away with it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: